K, so I back-slid to Phantasy Star I last weekend after trying in vain to enjoy Phantasy Star II and Phantasy Star III. The later games have not aged-well, but, even though I can't stand some of the "puzzles" (too much repetition involved) of the first Phantasy Star title, the game itself is not so bad.
There is something very charming about the way the story in Phantasy Star unfolds, and I can see why so many people think it is a great game. I do not think it is "great", but it is "good", and it something worth playing, even in this modern age of games like Fallout 3.